So today the WoW “spyware” story really hit the goddamn bigtime. Everybody knows I’m not a big fan of the cocksuckers at Blizzard; after all, they’re not big on interoperability or innovation or even answering a few honest questions from their customers and fans but seriously, this whole “OH HOLY FUCK WOW PUTS SPYWARE ON MY COMPUTER” shit is so fucking fucked.
God dammit, if nobody else is gonna put a frame around this thing, I’m gonna.
Warden is not spyware. One of the things that spyware generally implies is that the program was either installed without the user’s permission or using some sleight-of-hand. No matter whether you like or hate Blizzard you have to admit that their users allow this to happen. They’re clearly informed of what the terms of use are and choose to allow this spying to occur.
Many other games use this kind of technology. Punkbuster is definitely the name everybody’s been throwing around, and it’s a good point.
That said, there are a few points that are being made by sensible people (Bruce Schnier, for one, said that while Warden isn’t by and of itself dangerous, this is definitely a slippery slope) and a few arguments nobody is voicing, such as:
Why in the fuck do companies like Blizzard or Even Balance think it’s smart to keep all their detection methods and procedures under wraps? Why isn’t it smarter to let everybody know what you’re doing and be open about it? If you prowl around the WoW forums, you’ll find that the general consensus is that discussing Warden at all is grounds for getting banned. Not sure why, but that sort of oppressive bullshit is not good for anybody.
Blizzard has a habit of pissing on a lot of people, so it’s no big surprise that Hoglund’s post has sparked a huge nerd backlash. Hey, spend ten years pissing on anybody that tried to do anything even remotely interesting with your product, and people will (gasp!) be rather bitter about it.